AMIC is still one of the smaller names, and it doesn't operate in all 50 states. But many customers report high satisfaction with their insurance claims process and rates. They seem to maintain a competitive ranking and offer products people need to insure their homes, cars, and more. They seem to have minimal customer complaints with the BBB across states.
Austin Mutual Insurance Company's offerings rival many larger companies like State Farm or Allstate. Because of their size, they may provide a more local feel to their service. If you're looking for more than one insurance policy, always make sure to get quotes with the same companies. This way, you can get multi-policy and other discounts.