Best and Cheapest Homeowners Insurance in New Jersey for 2025 (10 Affordable Companies)

When searching for the best and cheapest homeowners insurance in New Jersey, these companies stand out, Allstate leads at $60 for a $200k policy with robust claim-free benefits, State Farm follows at $81 with extensive discounts, and USAA offers military members exceptional coverage at $82 with an A++ financial rating.

The best homeowners insurance in New Jersey changes a lot depending on the location. Coastal homes often have higher premiums plus specific rules.

Insurance Company	Rank	$200k Policy	A.M. Best	Best For	Jump to Pros/Cons
	#1	$60	A+	Claim-Free Benefits	Allstate
	#2	$81	B	Extensive Discounts	State Farm
	#3	$82	A++	Military Membership	USAA
	#4	$86	A++	Online Efficiency	Geico
	#5	$90	A+	Bundle Options	Nationwide
	#6	$96	A+	Competitive Pricing	Progressive
	#7	$100	A++	Green Initiatives	Travelers
	#8	$100	A	Flexible Plans	Liberty Mutual
	#9	$116	A	Loyalty Rewards	American Family
	#10	$118	A	Multiple Discounts	Farmers

Homeowners looking for affordable insurance in New Jersey find big savings through different discounts like combining policies installing smart home security systems, along with keeping claim free records. If you’re looking for cheap home insurance quote in NJ, compare rates now with our free quote tool.

What You Should Know

• Allstate leads NJ home insurance with exceptional value at $60/mo
• State Farm excels in local support and business coverage but has a lower B financial rating
• USAA offers superior A++ rated coverage for military families with special deployment protections

#1 – Allstate: Top Overall Pick

Pros

• Local Agency Network: New Jersey homeowners can access exceptional value with comprehensive $200k coverage packages across diverse policy selections.
• Personalized Service: Local New Jersey insurance agents deliver personalized consultations with rapid response times throughout the Garden State.
• Smart Home Discounts: Garden State residents with smart home security systems qualify for substantial insurance discounts year-round.

Cons

• Coastal Restrictions: New Jersey coastal property owners face significant premium increases within five miles of the Atlantic shoreline.
• New Buyer Limitations: First-time homeowners insurance applicants in New Jersey must meet stringent requirements before accessing premium discounts. Learn more about this limitation in our Allstate insurance review.

#2 – State Farm: Best for Local Support

Pros

• Bundle Savings: New Jersey residents combining auto and home insurance policies receive substantial yearly savings on property coverage.
• Business Coverage: Experienced agents provide detailed guidance for protecting New Jersey home-based businesses without requiring additional policies (Read More: State Farm insurance review).
• Quick Response: Quick claim response times throughout New Jersey suburban areas help homeowners recover swiftly after unexpected incidents.

Cons

• Financial Rating: The current financial rating might concern New Jersey homeowners who are seeking long-term stability with their insurance provider.
• Premium Costs: Base insurance premiums for New Jersey properties consistently run higher compared to other regional coverage options.

#3 – USAA: Best for Military Option

Pros

• Financial Strength: Military families in New Jersey benefit from its financial strength ensuring reliable coverage and swift claims.
• Deployment Protection: Special deployment protection covers unoccupied New Jersey homes while service members are stationed at distant locations.
• Military Perks: Garden State members near military installations receive competitive rates as listed in our USAA insurance review as well as additional home security feature discounts.

Cons

• Limited Eligibility: New Jersey coverage is limited exclusively to military personnel, veterans, and their immediate family members only.
• Office Locations: Limited physical office locations throughout New Jersey make in-person insurance consultations challenging for policyholders.

#4 – Geico: Best for Digital Experience

Pros

• Mobile Claims: New Jersey homeowners can file and track insurance claims entirely through user-friendly mobile applications (Read More: Homeowners Insurance Claim Check Questions).
• Quick Quotes: Advanced digital tools provide accurate New Jersey home insurance quotes in just a few minutes without the need for phone calls.
• Local Partnerships: Strong partnerships with local New Jersey underwriters get cheap rates across different property coverage types.

Cons

• Physical Presence: Limited physical locations across New Jersey make it difficult to have face-to-face meetings when discussing complex insurance claims.
• Customization Limits: Fewer customization options are available compared to traditional New Jersey insurance providers with a local office presence.

#5 – Nationwide: Best for Property Bundles

Pros

• Multi-Policy Savings: New Jersey residents receive significant savings when combining different types of property protection under one policy.
• Luxury Coverage: According to our Nationwide insurance review, the company's enhanced coverage options are designed specifically for luxury homes in northern New Jersey residential communities.
• Weather Protection: Specialized water damage protection packages safeguard Garden State properties against severe northeastern weather events.

Cons

• Stand-alone Rates: Stand-alone policy rates for New Jersey homes without bundling tend to exceed current market averages.
• Regional Limits: Coverage options become very limited in certain southern New Jersey neighborhoods and communities.

#6 – Progressive: Best for New Homeowners

Pros

• Rate Comparison: Transparent comparison tools help New Jersey customers find cheap rates that are suited to their specific situation. For in-depth information, visit the "Progressive Insurance Review" page.
• Payment Options: Flexible payment schedules allow Garden State homeowners to choose between convenient monthly or annual payments.
• New Construction: New Jersey residents purchasing coverage for newly constructed properties receive special insurance premium discounts.

Cons

• Storm Deductibles: Weather-related claim deductibles increase significantly for New Jersey coastal regions following severe storm events.
• Historic Homes: Historic New Jersey homes face coverage limitations and increased rates due to age-related risk factors.

#7 – Travelers: Best for Eco-Friendly Homes

Pros

• Green Benefits: New Jersey homeowners receive additional coverage benefits for environmentally conscious renovation projects and property improvements.
• Claim-Free Rewards: Garden State residents earn decreasing deductible benefits through consistent claim-free policy maintenance over time.
• Renewable Energy: Special protection packages safeguard renewable energy installations across New Jersey homes with sustainable features.

Cons

• Older Homes: As highlighted in our Travelers insurance review, premium rates increase substantially for New Jersey homes built before 1945 regardless of current condition.
• Coastal Guidelines: Strict underwriting guidelines apply for Garden State properties located within three miles of coastal areas.

#8 – Liberty Mutual: Best for Flexible Coverage

Pros

• Custom Deductibles: New Jersey customers can customize insurance deductibles for different claim types to match specific budget needs.
• Value Protection: Built-in inflation protection to keep coverage levels up with New Jersey property values that increase every year.
• Business Coverage: Options to cover NJ home-based businesses without needing a separate commercial policy.

Cons

• Location Rates: The characteristics of individual properties and their locations in New Jersey cause variations in insurance rates.
• Limited Discounts: As mentioned in our Liberty Mutual insurance review, the company's discount programs offer less substantial savings compared to leading New Jersey insurance market competitors.

#9 – American Family: Best for Long-Term Coverage

Pros

• Loyalty Rewards: Long-term New Jersey customers earn reduced deductibles through maintaining consistent claim-free insurance policy periods.
• Renovation Protection: Special coverage packages protect Garden State homes during major improvement projects and structural renovations.
• Smart Technology: Advanced protection options are available for New Jersey properties with integrated smart home technology systems (Read More: American Family Insurance Review).

Cons

• Limited Availability: Service availability remains limited across several regions throughout the Garden State insurance marketplace.
• Initial Costs: Initial New Jersey coverage rates start noticeably higher before loyalty benefits begin reducing overall costs.

#10 – Farmers: Best for Historic Properties

Pros

• Historic Expertise: Expert assessment teams understand unique insurance requirements for older New Jersey architectural home styles.
• Group Discounts: Garden State professional groups receive exclusive discount opportunities through established organizational insurance partnerships.
• Vacation Homes: New Jersey vacation property owners benefit from specialized coverage options for seasonal rental situations. To dive deeper, visit our Farmers insurance review.

Cons

• Higher Rates: Standard policy rates for New Jersey properties typically exceed average market prices for similar coverage.
• Documentation: Qualifying criteria for New Jersey premium discounts require more extensive documentation than other regional providers.

NJ Homeowners Insurance Rates

Grasping home insurance in New Jersey needs careful thought about coverage options plus costs. Comparing home insurance companies in NJ means looking at not just premiums but customer satisfaction along with claims processing.

Who has the cheapest homeowners insurance in New Jersey? The table below shows the current monthly rates for $200k policy, $300k policy, and $500k policy from major NJ homeowners insurance providers.

Insurance Company	$200k Policy	$300k Policy	$500k Policy
	$60	$81	$96
	$116	$149	$176
	$118	$174	$244
	$86	$99	$118
	$100	$150	$200
	$90	$156	$217
	$96	$118	$137
	$81	$101	$123
	$100	$172	$231
	$82	$106	$127

Here’s what the numbers say about home insurance in NJ. Recent ratings show an A- for claims handling and policyholder service. Insurance companies get a B+ for discounts, especially for bundling and new homes. Claims process gets a B, efficient but sometimes delayed.

These are the factors to consider when shopping for home insurance quotes. Newark and Jersey City have higher claim frequencies, so premiums are higher, but Allstate and State Farm have competitive rates across coverage levels. Getting the best home insurance in NJ means having a balance of good service and low rates.

Getting Savings for Homeowners Insurance in New Jersey

Finding cheap homeowners insurance in NJ comes down to understanding and utilizing the discounts available. The biggest savings come from bundling, being claims-free, and being loyal to your insurance company.

When shopping for home insurance quotes, NJ homeowners should review each company’s specific discounts. All major companies offer bundling discounts, but the savings can vary greatly between providers. Below is a list of all the discounts offered by each major NJ home insurance company:

Insurance Company	Bundling Home & Auto	Smoke/Fire Alarms	Full Payment Discount	Claims-Free	Senior/Homeowner
	25%	10%	5%	20%	15%
	20%	8%	5%	18%	10%
	20%	10%	6%	15%	12%
	15%	5%	4%	12%	8%
	25%	10%	5%	20%	15%
	20%	10%	5%	18%	12%
	15%	8%	4%	15%	10%
	25%	10%	5%	20%	15%
	20%	10%	5%	18%	12%
	25%	10%	5%	20%	15%

These discounts show how NJ homeowners can save big on their insurance while still being fully covered and avoid NJ homeowners insurance rate increase.

Have you heard of Drivewise? It's located in our Allstate app. We recently found out that customers who choose to use Drivewise are 25% less likely to have a severe collision than those who don't. https://t.co/HNMxg3hVAZ

— Allstate (@Allstate) May 13, 2024

Bundling always saves 25% but combining multiple discounts like safety features and claims free benefits can save even more on your NJ home owner insurance policy.

Coverage Options for Homeowners Insurance in New Jersey

Homeowners in New Jersey can choose from standard coverage like dwelling, personal property, liability, and additional living expenses, plus specialized options for unique risks.

Key add-ons include flood insurance for coastal areas, sewer backup, identity theft, and windstorm coverage for hurricanes and high winds.

Snow and ice damage coverage protects homes during harsh winters. Common risks include hurricanes, tornadoes, and winter storms, though New Jersey is less prone to earthquakes. Below are the common claims in New Jersey that highlight the importance of tailored coverage:

Most policies cover wind damage, damage from a natural disaster, earthquake damage, and flood coverage. City-specific data shows varying risk levels across major New Jersey municipalities, impacting coverage needs and premiums:

The best homeowners insurance in NJ should select coverage that addresses common regional risks, such as damage from winter storms, hurricane winds, and flooding. While New Jersey experiences fewer earthquakes, it is still important to have comprehensive protection against severe weather events to ensure sufficient home insurance.

Finding Your Ideal New Jersey Home Policy

The best and cheapest homeowners insurance in New Jersey are Allstate, State Farm, and USAA. Allstate captures attention with $60 monthly premiums for $200k coverage and generous claim-free rewards.

State Farm follows at $81 monthly, featuring diverse savings opportunities, while USAA delivers specialized military coverage at $82, backed by stellar A++ financial credentials. Check this review of the best homeowners insurance in New Jersey from reddit:

Comment
byu/EpicBk31 from discussion
innewjersey

Location matters in New Jersey insurance costs, and note that seaside properties require more coverage at higher rates. Don’t settle for expensive home insurance premiums. Enter your ZIP code to find NJ homeowners insurance companies at an affordable price.