Cheapest and Best Homeowners Insurance in Indiana as Rated by Customers in 2023
It may seem unlikely that you’ll have to file a homeowners insurance claim. But the reality is that there are many things that your home can experience that would require a claim. Having one of the best home insurance companies that sells in Indiana can put your mind at ease that if something were to happen, it would be handled quickly and without issues.
To help you be more confident in your homeowners insurance company, we have reviews and rankings for hundreds of homeowners insurance companies so you can evaluate and compare the best Indiana home insurance companies. In the table above, you can sort through every homeowners insurance company ranked on Clearsurance. Next to each insurer you’ll find the company’s rating, which is based exclusively on the reviews and ratings provided by customers. Note: Only those companies with at least 25 homeowners insurance reviews are eligible to appear in the best Indiana homeowners insurance rankings.
If you’re looking for additional information on one of the best homeowners insurance companies in Indiana, you can visit the company’s profile page where you’ll learn about the company, additional coverages and potential discounts offered. You can also read reviews to see what other policyholders have to say about the home insurance company.
On this page:
- Best homeowners insurance rates in Indiana for a $200K dwelling
- Best homeowners insurance rates in Indiana for a $400K dwelling
- Indiana property crime statistics
- Indiana disaster statistics
In the table below, compare the average homeowners insurance rates in Indiana for the five largest companies in the state. American Family Insurance ($1,092) and State Farm ($1,096) offer the cheapest homeowners insurance rates in Indiana for a $200K dwelling on average.
|Company||Average rates for $200K dwelling|
|American Family Insurance||$1,092|
|Auto-Owners Insurance Group||$1,622|
|Erie Insurance Group||$1,012|
|Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance||$1,258|
|State Farm Insurance Company||$1,096|
These rates are based on a $200,000 dwelling with the following coverage limits: $100,000 personal property, $20,000 loss of use, $20,000 other structures, $300,000 liability and $5,000 medical. The policy has a $1,000 deductible. The house used for the profile was constructed in 2004 and the individual had a good insurance score. The rates displayed should only be used for comparative purposes as individual rates in Indiana will differ. Rate data is provided by Quadrant Information Services.
American Family Insurance offers the cheapest average home insurance rates in Indiana for a $400K dwelling on average. Compare the homeowners insurance rates for five Indiana companies in the table below.
|Company||Average rates for $400K dwelling|
|American Family Insurance||$1,578|
|Auto-Owners Insurance Group||$2,715|
|Erie Insurance Group||$2,006|
|Indiana Farm Bureau Insurance||$2,147|
|State Farm Insurance Company||$1,728|
These rates are based on a $400,000 dwelling with the following coverage limits: $200,000 personal property, $40,000 loss of use, $40,000 other structures, $300,000 liability and $5,000 medical. The policy has a $1,000 deductible. The house used for the profile was constructed in 2004 and the individual had a good insurance score. The rates displayed should only be used for comparative purposes as individual rates in Indiana will differ. Rate data is provided by Quadrant Information Services.
Theft and vandalism or malicious mischief are among the 16 perils a standard homeowners insurance policy protects you from. So, how does crime in Indiana compare to other states around the country? The FBI published the following statistics on crime in Indiana for 2016:
- Property crime - 171,759
- Burglary - 34,097
- Larceny theft - 122,931
All three statistics for Indiana, when compared to the national average rate per 100,000 inhabitants, rank slightly above the national average.
Weather-related incidents are typically among the costliest homeowners insurance claims. FEMA has published statistics for each state since 1953. Data is updated through August 2018. Here’s a look at the Indiana federally declared disasters since 1953:
- Severe storm - 24
- Flood - 12
- Snow - 6
- Tornado - 4
- Hurricane - 1
- Severe ice storm - 1
How are homeowners insurance rates calculated in Indiana?
Ever wonder why you pay what you do to insure your home in Indiana? Some things may be obvious, like the age of your home. But other factors that contribute to the price of homeowners insurance may not be as obvious. Here’s a list of some of the things homeowners insurance companies consider when quoting you a rate:
- The level of coverage required
- The size of your mortgage
- Your credit score
- The square footage of your home
- The geographic location of your home in Indiana
- The condition of your home
- The age of your home
- The proximity of your home to a fire station
- Your previous claims record
- The amount of your deductible
- Optional add-ons like umbrella insurance
Zillow estimates that homeowners can expect to pay approximately $35 each month for every $100,000 of your home's value. The average cost of homeowners insurance in Indiana is lower than the national average. The lower-than-average cost of homeowners insurance in Indiana is likely due to its lower number of natural disasters. However, rates may increase due to natural disasters such as flooding or tornadoes. Flooding is not covered by homeowners insurance, but tornado damage should be covered in Indiana.
Other common causes of insurance loss include: fire, smoke, windstorm, hail and lightning, freezing, identity and credit card theft, trees and other falling objects.
Most common coverage options included in a standard homeowners policy include: dwelling coverage, other structures, personal property coverage, and loss of use. Flood insurance is offered separately from standard home policies.
How does Clearsurance rates and ranks the best homeowners insurance companies in Indiana?
Consistent with its mission towards greater transparency, Clearsurance does not keep its rating and ranking formulas in a black box. Our algorithm analyzes a range of inputs from our independent community of insurance customers, including:
- Customer Service
- Claim service
- Likelihood to renew
The algorithm also takes into account the percentage of what customers say the company does well vs. the percentage of what customers say the company could do better.
The Clearsurance customer ratings and rankings are derived entirely from customer reviews and ratings.
Homeowners Insurance Guide
Your home is likely your most valuable asset, making it that much more important that you insure your home with one of the best Indiana homeowners insurance companies. But beyond just picking a company, it’s crucial to have the right coverage and to understand that coverage. Did you know that a standard homeowners insurance policy has six types of coverage? And did you know that there are usually 16 types of perils found in a homeowners insurance policy?
At Clearsurance, we want to make sure you have a strong understanding of your homeowners insurance coverage and what it all means. Check out our homeowners insurance guide to become a smarter insurance customer. And for more educational content on other homeowners insurance topics, check out our homeowners insurance blog!